Repair notes

Chasing Down That Annoying Chain Noise in Your Garage

Nothing drives me crazier than a mysterious chain noise. You know the one - that click, creak, or grinding sound that happens every pedal stroke or maybe just when you shift. Last month I spent three evenings in my freezing garage tracking down a noise that turned out to be something completely different than I expected. Here's what I've learned about methodically hunting down chain noises without losing your mind or your fingers to the cold.

Start With the Obvious Stuff Because I Never Do

I always want to jump to the complicated diagnosis, but honestly, most chain noise is dirt, rust, or a dry chain. Before you do anything else, get your work stand set up if you have one, or flip the bike upside down if you don't. Spin the cranks slowly and listen. A dry chain sounds like a whisper of metal on metal. A dirty chain often clicks or crunches. If your chain looks like you rode through a mud pit or hasn't been lubed since last summer, clean it first. I use a rag with degreaser and run the chain through it while backpedaling, then let it dry, then lube it properly. Not soaking it, just a drop on each roller, then wipe off the excess. I've wasted so much time diagnosing problems that were just dirt.

Check for Stiff Links and Worn Components

This one gets me every single time. A stiff link will cause a click or skip that happens at the same point in every pedal rotation. Slowly backpedal the chain and watch it go through the rear derailleur pulley wheels. You're looking for a link that doesn't bend smoothly, one that kind of jerks as it goes around. Mark it with a bit of tape or just remember where it is. You can usually work a stiff link loose by flexing it side to side with your hands, but if it's rusted or the pin is damaged, that link needs replacing. While you're looking, check your chainring teeth for hooking or wear, and look at your cassette cogs too. Worn teeth look like shark fins instead of rounded peaks. A worn chain on worn cogs will make all kinds of noise, and there's no adjustment that fixes it - you just need new parts. I learned this the hard way after adjusting my derailleur forty times.

The Derailleur and Hanger Rabbit Hole

If your chain is clean and nothing's obviously worn, start looking at derailleur adjustment and hanger alignment. A bent derailleur hanger will cause the chain to run at an angle, which creates noise and poor shifting. You can eyeball it from behind the bike - the derailleur cage should be parallel to the cassette cogs. If it's not, your hanger might be bent. I don't have an alignment tool, so I take it to the shop for that, but you can see obvious bends yourself. For adjustment, check that your limit screws are set so the chain isn't trying to shift off either end of the cassette. Then check cable tension - if your chain is rubbing on the front derailleur cage or the shifts are sloppy in back, you probably need a quarter turn on the barrel adjuster. Make tiny adjustments. I always overdo it and make things worse. Also check that your derailleur pulleys spin freely and aren't worn into a groove. A pulley bearing that's gone bad will squeak or grind.

The Weird Stuff That Sounds Like Chain Noise But Isn't

After all that, if you still have noise, start looking elsewhere because I've been fooled so many times. Bottom bracket issues sound exactly like chain noise - a click or creak every pedal stroke. Check for play by holding the crank arms and trying to wiggle them side to side. Also check that your chainring bolts are tight. A loose chainring bolt will click rhythmically and drive you insane. Pedal bearings can click too. Even a loose cassette lockring can make noise that sounds like it's coming from the chain. Last month my mystery noise turned out to be my rear quick release skewer, which wasn't tight enough. The wheel was shifting slightly in the dropouts under load. Felt like an idiot, but at least my drivetrain got a thorough cleaning and adjustment out of it. Sometimes in a cold garage with numb fingers, you just have to accept that bikes make noises and come back to it another day with fresh ears.

Questions people ask me